Modals of Possibility in English
Possibility Modals
This article is part of the English grammar tree on Settemila Lingue.
In Brief
Use may, might, or could when something is possible but uncertain: The keys might be upstairs. Use must for a conclusion you believe is almost certainly true and can't for one you believe is impossible: She must be home; the lights are on. She can't be asleep; I can hear her talking.
Overview
English modal verbs let you show how certain you are without claiming that you know a fact. A modal verb is a helping verb such as may or must that adds a meaning like possibility, necessity, or certainty to another verb. Compare Leo is at work, which sounds like a fact, with Leo might be at work, which presents only one possible explanation.
At B1, the central contrast is between open possibility and logical deduction. May, might, and could leave more than one explanation open. Must and can't express a strong conclusion based on evidence or reasoning. This use of must is not an order, and this use of can't is not about ability.
These forms are common in everyday conversations, news reports, workplace discussions, and any situation where people make careful predictions or interpret evidence. They help you avoid sounding more certain than your information allows.
How It Works
The basic pattern
A modal is followed by the base form of a verb—the plain form without to, such as be, know, or arrive.
| Meaning | Pattern | Example |
|---|---|---|
| Possibility | subject + may/might/could + base verb | Nina might know the answer. |
| Strong positive deduction | subject + must + base verb | Nina must know the answer. |
| Strong negative deduction | subject + can't + base verb | Nina can't know the answer yet. |
The modal does not change for person or number:
- I might leave.
- She might leave.
- They might leave.
Do not add -s in the third person, and do not place to after the modal. Most possibility modals also do not use do/does to form questions or negatives.
A practical certainty scale
The exact degree of certainty depends on context and the speaker, so these are not mathematical percentages. The scale is nevertheless useful:
| Speaker's judgment | Typical form | Example |
|---|---|---|
| Almost certainly true | must | That must be the delivery driver. |
| Possibly true | may / might / could | That might be the delivery driver. |
| Almost certainly not true | can't | That can't be the delivery driver; the order was cancelled. |
May, might, and could often overlap. May can sound slightly more formal, especially in writing. Might sometimes suggests a more tentative possibility, but speakers do not apply a fixed certainty ranking consistently. Could often emphasizes that something is one possible explanation or outcome.
Present states and actions
With a state, the modal commonly comes before be or another plain verb:
- The office may be empty.
- He might know her.
- This could mean we are early.
- You must be hungry.
- That can't belong to Sam.
For an action in progress, use modal + be + verb-ing. The -ing form describes the ongoing action:
- They might be waiting outside.
- Maya must be working late.
- He can't be driving; his car is here.
Future possibility
The same modal pattern can refer to the future when a time expression or the situation makes the timing clear:
- It may rain tonight.
- We might finish by Friday.
- The meeting could run late.
Do not add will after these modals: not might will rain, but might rain. English normally allows only one central modal in this position.
Negatives
For uncertain negative possibility, put not after may or might:
- She may not come.
- The shop might not be open.
These mean that non-arrival or closure is possible. Could not can also express possibility in some contexts, but it is easily read as past inability: He could not attend usually means that he was unable to attend. For a clear uncertain prediction, might not is often safer.
For a strong negative deduction, use can't or, more formally, cannot:
- This can't be the correct address.
- The figures cannot be accurate.
Do not confuse can't with mustn't. Can't be true means “I conclude that it is not true.” Mustn't usually expresses prohibition: You mustn't tell anyone means “Do not tell anyone.”
Questions about possibility
Questions often use could or might before the subject:
- Could the email be in your spam folder?
- Might there be another explanation?
Might questions are relatively formal. In ordinary conversation, could, is it possible that, or do you think ... might is more natural. May it be ...? is generally not the normal way to ask about probability.
Evidence, not absolute fact
Deductive must and can't report the speaker's conclusion. They do not guarantee that the conclusion is correct:
- The curtains are closed, so they must be away.
The speaker feels sure because of the evidence, but the people could simply be asleep. If you directly know the fact, use an ordinary statement: They are away.
Examples in Context
| English | Meaning in plain English | Note |
|---|---|---|
| She might come tomorrow. | Perhaps she will come tomorrow. | Tentative future possibility |
| It could be true. | It is one possible explanation. | Open possibility |
| The package may arrive this afternoon. | An afternoon arrival is possible. | Neutral; slightly formal |
| We might not have enough chairs. | Perhaps we do not have enough chairs. | Uncertain negative |
| Could the noise be coming from upstairs? | Is upstairs a possible source of the noise? | Possibility question |
| He must be tired after that night shift. | I am nearly certain he is tired. | Positive deduction from context |
| Those must be Priya's glasses. | I strongly conclude that the glasses belong to Priya. | Deduction with plural be |
| The neighbors must be having a party. | The evidence strongly suggests an ongoing party. | Deduction about an action now |
| She can't be fifty. | I believe it is impossible that she is fifty. | Strong negative deduction |
| This can't be our train; it is going south. | The evidence rules out this train. | Negative deduction with a reason |
| Jamie can't be sleeping—the music is very loud. | I am almost sure Jamie is not asleep. | Negative deduction about an action now |
| The roads could be busy later. | Busy roads are a possible future situation. | Future possibility |
| I may stay home tonight, but I haven't decided. | Staying home is a possible plan. | Undecided intention |
| That can't be right. The total should be £85. | I strongly believe the result is wrong. | Common reaction to conflicting evidence |
Common Mistakes
Adding to after a modal
- Wrong: She might to arrive late.
- Right: She might arrive late.
- Why: A modal takes the base verb directly, without to.
Adding a third-person -s
- Wrong: He may comes later.
- Right: He may come later.
- Why: The modal carries the grammatical role; the following verb stays in its base form.
Using do with a modal
- Wrong: Does it might rain?
- Right: Might it rain? / Do you think it might rain?
- Why: In a direct modal question, move the modal before the subject. Do not add do.
Treating deductive must as an obligation
- Misleading interpretation: He must be at home means someone ordered him to stay home.
- Intended meaning: He must be at home; his coat is here.
- Why: Before a state such as be at home, context can make must a strong logical conclusion rather than a rule or duty.
Using mustn't for an impossible conclusion
- Wrong: That mustn't be Elena; Elena is in Madrid.
- Right: That can't be Elena; Elena is in Madrid.
- Why: For a strong negative deduction, use can't. Mustn't normally tells someone that an action is forbidden.
Assuming might always means less likely than may
- Too rigid: “Use may for 50% and might for 30%.”
- Better: It may rain and It might rain can express the same uncertain forecast.
- Why: Tone, dialect, context, and personal style matter more than fixed percentages.
Usage Notes
Formality and tone
May appears frequently in formal announcements, reports, and careful writing: Delays may occur during maintenance. In conversation, might and could are very common. None of the three is restricted to one register, however.
The full form cannot is usual in formal writing and when the negative needs emphasis. Can't is standard in speech and ordinary writing. In pronunciation, stressed can't is important because it contrasts with can in many accents.
Possibility is not permission or ability
The same modals have other jobs. May I leave? asks permission. I could swim at six describes past ability. Context normally makes the meaning clear:
- Alex may leave early because the manager agreed. — permission
- Alex may leave early if the meeting ends quickly. — possibility
- Rosa could read before she started school. — past ability
- Rosa could be in the library. — present possibility
Giving a reason
Strong deductions sound most natural when the evidence is visible in the conversation. Words such as because, so, and a following dash can make the reasoning explicit:
- His phone is off, so he might be on the plane.
- She must be nearby—her bag is still here.
- It can't be midnight because the last bus hasn't left.
Without evidence, must can sound too confident. Choose may, might, or could when you are only suggesting an option.
Beyond the Basics: Advanced Use
Degrees of confidence in real discourse
Advanced speakers often combine modals with adverbs and reporting phrases rather than relying on the modal alone:
- It may possibly take longer than expected.
- She could well be right.
- I think they might be waiting for us.
- That must surely be a mistake.
Could well means that the possibility deserves serious consideration. Surely invites the listener to share the speaker's strong conclusion, though tone can make it sound challenging or surprised.
May not can be ambiguous
You may not enter can mean either “Perhaps you will not enter” or, more commonly in the right context, “You are not permitted to enter.” Avoid ambiguity by choosing a clearer form:
- Uncertain possibility: You might not get into the building after six.
- Prohibition: You are not allowed to enter this area.
Alternative ways to express probability
English has a wider scale than these five modals:
| Expression | Typical force |
|---|---|
| perhaps / maybe | Open possibility |
| probably / likely | More likely than not |
| almost certainly | Very strong expectation |
| definitely / certainly | Presented as certain |
Compare She might come with She will probably come. Both avoid a firm factual promise, but probably usually presents her arrival as the more likely outcome.
Deductions about the past
To reason about an earlier event, English uses modal + have + past participle, where a past participle is a verb form such as gone, seen, or finished: They might have missed the train; he must have forgotten; she can't have seen the message. This is an important next-stage pattern and has its own contrasts. Do not use a simple form when the deduction clearly concerns a completed past event: He must forget yesterday is not the equivalent of He must have forgotten yesterday.
Practice Tips
- Build an evidence chain. Choose an everyday clue—wet umbrellas, a locked door, an unanswered phone—and write three conclusions: one with might/could, one with must, and one with can't.
- Use a certainty ladder. Rewrite one statement as It must be ..., It may/might/could be ..., and It can't be .... Notice how the factual content stays similar while your commitment changes.
- Listen for function, not only form. When you hear must or could, ask whether it expresses deduction, obligation, ability, permission, or possibility. Save the full sentence, because context determines the meaning.
Related Concepts
- Prerequisite: Should and Must — reviews the basic form of modal verbs and the obligation meaning of must.
- Next step: Modal Verbs: Past Deduction — extends possibility and deduction to earlier events with may have, might have, must have, and can't have.
- Later refinement: Hedging Language — develops more subtle ways to limit certainty and soften claims in formal and academic English.